If you want to add a rental unit or space for family, the two most common options are converting your garage or building a new detached ADU. Both can be a great investment. The right choice depends on your budget, your lot, and how you plan to use the space.
Garage Conversion
A garage conversion turns an existing attached or detached garage into a legal living unit with a kitchen, bathroom, insulation, and windows that meet code.
- Lower cost: the foundation, walls, and roof are already in place, so conversions usually cost significantly less than new construction.
- Faster timeline: less structural work means a shorter build.
- Parking: under California law, a city cannot require you to replace the parking spaces lost when a garage is converted to an ADU.
- Limits: the size and layout are set by the existing garage, and older garages may need slab, framing, or foundation upgrades.
Detached ADU
A detached ADU is a new, stand-alone home built in your backyard.
- More flexibility: you choose the size, layout, and placement within your city’s ADU standards.
- More privacy: a separate structure gives both households more separation, which can increase rental value.
- Higher cost: a new foundation, framing, roof, and longer utility runs make it the most expensive option.
- Longer timeline: design, engineering, and construction take more time than a conversion.
How to Decide
- If budget and speed matter most, and your garage is in good shape, a conversion is usually the better value.
- If you want the largest unit, the most privacy, or the highest rental income, a detached ADU is often worth the added cost.
- If your lot is small or steep, a conversion or attached ADU may be the only practical option.
The best way to compare is a site visit. We look at the condition of the garage, the yard, and the existing utilities, then price both options so you can make the decision with real numbers. Learn more about our ADU construction services.
Planning an ADU, addition, or remodel in Alameda or Contra Costa County? Schedule a walkthrough and get a written estimate from C. Watkins Construction, a licensed, bonded, and insured general contractor (CSLB #1118850).